UMTRR July, 1999 || Edited From Subscriber Edition
©1999-2001 George J. Irwin. All rights reserved. Legal Stuff

N SCALE NEW RELEASES:

55430, $21.65 - 33' Two Bay Hopper, Offset Sides, Cambria and Indiana (Bicentennial). Black with large red, white and blue stripes and blue and red reporting marks. American flag outlined in gold in center. Herald on right. Reporting Marks: C&I 1976. Approximate Time Period: mid 1970's. NOTE: This item has been sold out and discontinued.

This is the most expensive hopper ever released by Micro-Trains by a long shot, but for a valid reason: When was the last time you saw a five color paint job on a coal car?

Coal car, yep, that's what it is. The Cambria and Indiana is named for the counties in which it resides-- and that's present tense because it's still around. In 1954, it operated from a connection with the New York Central at Manver, Pennsylvania to an interchange with the Pennsylvania 28 miles away at Nanty Glo-- spelled Nant-Y-Glo in the Official Guide of the Railways entry, thank you. Two branches added another 8 miles to the line. And the principal traffic was coal, lots and lots of coal.

But the valley of the Blacklick River where the C&I runs was also once famous for steel, and iron. In fact, the Cambria Iron Company was the largest producer of iron rails in America in the 1870's, and was an early innovator in the steel business as well. Its original plant in Cambria County is now a national historical landmark.

The Cambria Steel Company was purchased in 1923 by Bethlehem Steel, which had been making Bessemer steel rails since 1873. The Cambria and Indiana Railroad apparently came with the package; the 1954 Official Guide lists the C&I's offices as being in Bethlehem. Bethlehem Steel lists the line as one of six "switching and terminal railroads" that it owns. The company's site has a page "Subsidiary Railroads" which states that the "railroad companies own and operate approximately 100 switcher locomotives and 900 freight cars."

It used to be a lot more than that. The C&I itself is listed with 1,991 hoppers under its name in the February 1963 Official Railway Equipment Register. However, none of these are numbered 1776. Let's try the April 1976 book: That's better. Series 1600 to 1999 is of 367 33 foot hoppers, coal, self clearing. And what do you know, 1976 fits right into that series, so the folks in Cambria County did that one up a little special for the Nation's 200th birthday. It is a unique car, and folks, you already know what that means. By the way, the C&I also did a similar, but not identical, treatment, to hopper #1776, which was included in the C&I Special Edition set, released June 2000 (see that description here).

Long strings of C&I 100 ton hoppers-- not the 33 footers that are the 55000 series-- used to appear literally in my backyard when I lived up near the "Charlotte Runner" Conrail line that was used to bring coal to a local generating station. More recently, though, I've observed the same C&I hoppers, still wearing the squarish herald, with hastily restenciled "BSIX" reporting marks-- sometimes even retaining the "I" from "C&I"! That would be Bethlehem Steel, of course, and may explain why the six railroads are listed as owning just 900 cars.

67120, $19.25 - 45' Trailer, Burlington Northern City View "St. Louis". White with multicolor "city view" mural across side. Reporting Marks: BNZ 237895. Approximate Time Period: late 1980's to mid 1990's. NOTE: This item has been sold out and discontinued.

Since we cover historical data on railroads and private owners here in the UMTRR, why not a brief historical look at the place honored on the City View trailer?

The Burlington Northern is now a "fallen flag," but processes and bureaucracies being what they are, it usually takes a while from merger proposal to reality. Usually it's years. St. Louis can beat that easily; how about two fallen flags in less than 48 hours time? "Three Flags Day", actually the two days March 9 and 10, 1804, marked the change from Spanish to United States rule. While "Upper Louisiana" was technically under Spanish jurisdiction, the settlement was populated mostly by the French, who'd originally controlled the area. (Yes, from my schoolbooks, I seem to remember that we bought "all" of the Louisiana Purchase from France, so I'm not sure how this worked either.) So in deference to the French, U.S. Military Governor Major Amos Stoddard, accompanied by Captain Meriwether Lewis (who'd later get a partner named Clark) ordered that the French flag be allowed to fly over St. Louis for twenty four hours before the Stars and Stripes replaced it. So the Spanish flag came down, the French flag went up, next day the French flag went down, the US flag went up, and there's two "fallen flags". What do you mean, they're not railroads? For more on this time period in the history of the Gateway City, check out the site of "Scott's Time Portal to Old St. Louis," part of The American Local History Network.

One hundred years later, in 1904, Forest Park in St. Louis played host to the World's Fair, where newfangled developments like this thing called "electricity" were being displayed and the ice cream cone was somewhat inadvertantly sold for the first time. That same year what's been called "the Strangest Olympics" were held in St. Louis as well. It was the country's first time as host of the Games, but due to the Russo-Japanese War and other circumstances, United States entrants constituted 85% of the 625 participants, and won 238 of the 282 medals. A Civil War veteran won the Archery medal! Fortunately, other Games hosted by the United States after this first foray would prove to be somewhat more mainstream!

And then, of course, there's the Arch, or, more properly, the Jefferson National Expansion Memorial, of which the Gateway Arch is only a part. Eero Saarinen won a national competition for its design; the Arch was started in 1963 and completed in 1965. It is 630 feet high and sways up to 18 inches in strong winds. I've been there; my friends in St. Louis still wonder how I could have walked there from Forest Park in five degree weather in the middle of January! Well, the sun was out and it felt warm! The stainless steel arch sums up for me and for others a remarkable history of the area and what it symbolized for a country towards its "manifest destiny."

77040, $11.05 - 50' Steel Box Car without roofwalk, Single Door, United States Navy. Gray with black lettering including initials, serial number and dimensional data. Reporting Marks: USN 61-05146. Approximate Time Period: technically the late 1990's, but see below. NOTE: This item has been sold out and discontinued.

If this new release were anything but a military car, it would probably meet with ferocious yawns from the accumulating community. However, the military theme is pretty hot these days, and the fact that this car fits right into today's railroading will be of interest. Oh, I should get right to the Approximate Time Period dicussion: I'm taking some liberties with it-- if you'll pardon the expression. While it's possible that this car was renumbered when repainted in 1997, the paint scheme itself has probably been the standard Government Issue for much longer than that. So I'm going with the lack of roofwalk as the determining factor and suggesting that you go ahead and run this car on pikes set in the 1970's and forward. If you're not that much of a stickler for captive service, that is. What do I mean? Read on!

It took me quite a bit of digging around through various Navy websites to find a reasonably definitive history of the station; along the way I discovered the procedure for obtaining a fishing pass (you've got to be connected with the base or the Navy), and information on a "Fear the Pier" 5-K run that took place on June 26 of this year. (Wonder who won?) Anyway, here's the scoop from that location (no longer accessible):

"When a pressing need developed during World War II for an ammunition depot in the greater New York area, a site in Monmouth County, New Jersey was chosen. The location provided two distinct areas. A waterfront location provided ships with a safe and operationally advantageous port to take on ammunition, while an inland storage area, safe from possible submarine bombardment, provided access to commercial rail facilities with lines coming from the west, where the majority of ammunition shipments originated. On August 2, 1943, construction began and in a short time, storage bunkers, a road and rail network, numerous buildings, and a pier complex were built. Named after Rear Admiral Ralph Earle, Chief of the Bureau of Ordnance during World War I, the Station was commissioned on December 13, 1943 as the Naval Ammunition Depot Earle. Earle continued to develop after World War II, keeping pace with the changing needs of the Navy, and in 1974 was redesignated the Naval Weapons Station (NWS) Earle, which remains the Station’s name today.

"The Mainside area, which is located mainly in Colts Neck, is more than 10,000 acres which contains ordnance storage areas and the majority of Earle’s departments and facilities. Mainside is in many ways like a small town with its own police and fire departments, homes, office buildings, restaurants, and recreational facilities. Mainside and the Waterfront area are connected by Normandy Road, a 15-mile military road and rail line.

"The Waterfront area is located on Sandy Hook Bay in Leonardo. The trident-shaped pier complex extends 2.2 miles into Sandy Hook Bay and comprises 2.9 miles of pier/trestle area. Four Fast Combat Support ships, USS Seattle (AOE 3), USS Detroit (AOE 4), USS Supply (AOE 6), and USS Arctic (AOE 8), are homeported at the pier complex. The pier is fully capable of providing ammunition to nearly every class of ship operated by the United States Navy and Coast Guard."

Plying that Normandy Road line and the rest of the trackage of the weapons station were some rather unusual locomotives including some rare Baldwin switchers. They didn't leave the property and I doubt that this car did either. It appears to be subject to captive service, of the most dangerous kind-- explosives! However, the paint job is generic enough to allow a little leeway in the N Scale utilization of this car, just as it enables a stretch backward in the Approximate Time Period.


N SCALE REPRINTS:

20446, $9.65 - 40' Single Door Box Car (Youngstown or "Narrow Rib" Door), United States Air Force. "Stratus" blue with white lettering including Air Force logo on right. Reporting Marks: DAFX 26475. Approximate Time Period: decade of the 1950's. Previous Release: Road Number 26477, July 1998. NOTE: This item has been sold out and discontinued.

This item was a fairly fast sellout in its first release. We do know from last year's research that the car is in neither the April 1952 ORER nor the January 1964; that doesn't necessarily mean it didn't exist, but that it didn't necessarily move in interchange service. The '64 book noted that the entire DAFX reporting mark was gone, replaced by a blurb that all cars in military service were being restenciled "DODX" which consolidated Department of Defense equipment. That didn't last, and the DAFX reporting marks returned by 1970. So, in summary, we'll take MTL's word for it when they say the car was built "a few years after the Department of the Air Force was established" in 1947. Come to think of it, that's a bit nebulous too...

And once again in the relentless pursuit of useless trivia-- or maybe it comes to me, I don't know-- we turn to a recent broadcast of a vintage episode of the game show "To Tell The Truth" on the cable channel Game Show Network. For those of you who don't necessarily participate in this highly cultural diversion (!) the game works like this: Three people claim to be a specific person but (obviously) only one is the real McCoy, and two are imposters. A celebrity panel asks questions of the three contestants to try to discern which one of the three is the actual person. The episode to which I refer first aired in 1951 and had as a challenger one of the graduating class from the Air Force Academy-- the class! After the real Air Force Academy graduate please stood up, there was a brief discussion of the then new facility in Colorado Springs. Not PBS, but not bad.

Prior to its "spinoff" as a seperate department, the Air Force was part of the Army; according to its official website, though, the idea of the Air Force was proposed all the way back in 1905, when two inventors from Dublin, Ohio offered to build for the War Department a heavier than air flying machine. Yep, those would be the Wright Brothers, who patented the airplane in 1906. The Signal Corps was the first home for aviators; however, their first real attempt at supporting combat, at the beginning of United States involvement in World War I, was not as successful as they might have preferred. The story goes on from there, of course, at their website.

20456, $9.65, 40' Single Door Box Car (Youngstown or "Narrow Rib" Door), United States Army. "Olive drab" green with white lettering including Transportation Corps logo on right. Reporting Marks: USAX 24679. Approximate Time Period: 1949 through 1958. Previous Release: Road Number 24678, July 1998. NOTE: This item has been sold out and discontinued.

This reprint, like its predecessor, carries the herald of the Transportation Corps, which was "officially" organized on July 31, 1942. But a page on the Army's sprawling website notes that "the historical background of the Transportation Corps starts with World War I." The Quartermaster General had most of the responsibility for getting material to the front lines, and elsewhere, prior to that time.

Although our ORER accumulation provides no significant insight into the prototypes of the Air Force and Navy cars above, it does provide a small ration of info in the April 1952 book. The series from 24677 to 24681, of five cars, reports for duty there. They're of 40 foot 6 inch outside length, which is a rivet counting bit short of the model; and are marked to carry 80,000 pounds. MTL remarks that the cars were renumbered in 1958 so it doesn't surprise me that they're not in my January 1964 ORER.

So you've now got two box cars, two flats, and one tank car decorated for the Army, and with the Transportation Corps logo, in fact. The flat car is catalog number 45180 and the tank car is 65370. Despite relatively quick sales on the flats and the run on the box car's first release, you should not have to shell out a bunch of bucks for any of these USAX cars. At times on eBay they've not even reached their original list prices, though a small premium is a more realistic expectation for accumulators that need to fill these in.

39060, $13.30 - 40' Double Sheathed Wood Boxcar with Vertical Brake Wheel, Santa Fe (AT&SF). Box car red with white lettering and black and white square "circle cross" herald on right. Reporting Marks: ATSF 38693 C.T. (for "Columbia Trust," see below). Approximate Time Period: At least the 1920's but possibly into the 1940's. Previous Releases: Road Number 38691 (in widely acknowledged "tuscan" and "dark brown" color variations), February 1986; Road Number 38616, February 1991. NOTE: This item has been sold out and discontinued.

You don't need to stretch too far to bring this reprint into the patriotism and/or military themes that dominate the month's lineup; the "C.T." after the road number is the tipoff. It stands for "Columbia Trust" and means that this particular piece of rolling stock was acquired under the auspices of the United States Railroad Administration. Hmm, sounds governmental. It is.

Keith L. Bryant Jr., in the book "History of the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway", describes what life was like on the line while under Federal control from December 1917 to March 1920. "Operation of the Santa Fe by the USRA produced mixed results," he concluded. It probably was to the ATSF's benefit that the person who ended up overseeing day to day operations of the USRA was one Edward Chambers, who had once been chair of the Santa Fe's board of directors. That may have meant mixed results instead of the disaster that befell some other lines. Even so, the "rent" paid by the USRA was significantly less than the line projected it could have taken in as a private carrier during the boom times of the First World War. In addition, the line still had to pay taxes, and it was compelled to repair any company's frieght cars at its shops, which resulted in costs for maintenance more then doubling from 1916 to 1919. The labor movement won some important gains during USRA control, and they kept them after the railroads were returned to the private sector. The Transportation Act of 1920 was a new governmental approach to railroad regulation which at least intended to incorporated the "lessons learned" from the USRA experience. Which, on balance, wasn't a good experience.

This Columbia Trust boxcar belonged to the series 37001 to 39700, of a whopping 2,670 as listed in the April 1928 ORER. The "C.T." is called out as part of the number series in that issue, by the way. The February 1931 book shows 2,656 cars. The large series is split up by the February 1952 ORER, with just 305 cars left in the 37000's and none remaining in the 38000's. But I think that the removal of the "C.T." and the Andrews trucks (new for this iteration) would probably predate the removal from the roster, so I'm calling the APT closed at the early 1940's.

65012, $33.00 - A two-pack of 65010, 39' Tank Car, Single Dome, Santa Fe (AT&SF). Black with white lettering including reporting marks on left. Reporting Marks: AT&SF 100823 and 100886. Approximate Time Period: at least the 1950's through the 1970's. Previous Release: A five-pack, road numbers 100800, 100854, 100863, 100877, 100899, May 1980. NOTE: This item has been sold out and discontinued.

"They must be playing games," reported the head of the Irwin Library's main branch-- my dad, that is-- upon looking up these reprints in his ORERs. "In the 1931 book, there is a series from 100800 to 100899, and the cars are listed as 32 feet 7 inches long. But in the April 1952 book, the cars got bigger! They are 39 foot 5 inches long with an inside length of 35 foot 7 inches. But there are still 100 cars in the series."

OK, so now what do we do for an Approximate Time Period? Well, I do know that there can be some interesting interpretations of the built date on a car-- for example, an issue of Rail Model Journal has a photo of a steel ATSF box car that was rebuilt from a wood side car-- and carried a built date of 1912! So we could be looking at a rebuild, a stretch, a new frame, or a bunch of other ideas. Hopefully, we'll be looking at some Incremental Information from you Santa Fe experts out there as well! Well, wherever the ATP starts, it definitely runs through February 1964, where we find 99 of 100 still listed, into April 1970, with 87 remaining, and even to April 1981, with 74 rolling along. In that issue of the ORER the ATSF boasted 1,090 tank cars-- more than most of the private owners! The October 1986 listing shows no trace of the 100800 series, though.


Nn3 SCALE (NARROW GAUGE):
A reprint this month:

15101, $14.50 - 30' Wood Box Car, Denver and Rio Grande Western. Box car red with white lettering including "Scenic Line" herald on right. Road number: 3375. Approximate Time Period: 1930's at least. Previous Releases: Road Number 3074, May 1988; Road Number 3066, release date not known; Road Number 3187, March 1991; Road Number 3194, March 1992. Note: This item has been sold out and discontinued.

This reprint honors both of the lines through the Rockies that were part of the Rio Grande. However, both the Moffat Route and the Royal Gorge Route were principally standard gauge lines, and this is a narrow gauge car! So let's take a brief look at the narrow gauge empire of the Rio Grande. There was a line from Salida on the Royal Gorge Route, winding west to Gunnison and Montrose, and then northward to rejoin the standard gauge main line at Grand Junction. Off of this line was a branch to Ridgway and connection to the legendary Rio Grande Southern to Durango. From there the Rio Grande picked up again to head to Chama, Antonito and into New Mexico, and all the way back to the standard gauge in Eastern Colorado. And, oh, let's not forget the Durango to Silverton line which still operates today. Talk about a scenic line! In addition, the Royal Gorge line did start as narrow gauge as well but was at the 56.5" width between the rails well before the Approximate Time Period for this car.

Speaking of which, the ORER for April 1928 shows 719 thirty foot box cars in the series 3000 to 3749. The CDS Railway Equipment Diagrams book notes that the "Royal Gorge" herald was used from 1924 to 1936 and the "Moffat Tunnel" herald from 1936 to 1941, at which time the "speed lettering" debuted. So I'm being conservative with the Approximate Time Period. Narrow gauge experts, please feel free to expand it.


Z SCALE NEW RELEASES:

13515, Marklin Coupler, $13.85;
13515-2, Micro-Trains Coupler, $15.50;
50' Single Door Box Car, United States Navy.

Gray with black lettering. Road Number: 61-05146. Approximate Time Period: 1950's to 1970's. NOTE: This item (both versions) has been sold out and discontinued.

Please see the N Scale car description, with the exception that the Z scale version has a roofwalk, while the N Scale version doesn't. So that changes the Approximate Time Period, in my estimation (read: guess), to a time when there were roofwalks.


Z SCALE REPRINTS:
No releases this month.